A mural depicting Salvadoran Archbishop Oscar Romero is seen in 2005 outside the San Salvador hospital where he was killed while celebrating Mass, March 24, 1980.


A mural depicting Salvadoran Archbishop Oscar Romero is seen in 2005 outside the San Salvador hospital where he was killed while celebrating Mass, March 24, 1980.

February 23, 2015

Murdered Salvadoran Archbishop Oscar Romero is held up as a beacon for the poor and oppressed, but scholars who have studied Romero's life say his conversion to the poor was a slow process.

It's a common narrative that Romero had a sudden conversion from a quiet, cerebral archbishop to one whose outreach to the poor and disenfranchised led to his death.

However, Damian Zynda, a Romero researcher at Jesuit-run Creighton University, argues that transformation happened over many years.

Scholars see a significant shift in the archbishop's activism after the 1977 assassination of Father Rutilio Grande, a progressive Jesuit priest and friend of the archbishop who had been an unapologetic critic of what he called El Salvador's oppressive government.

But Zynda and other researchers suggest that event was only a trigger, and that his true evolution resulted from a series of conversions that occurred throughout Romero's life.

The sainthood cause for the archbishop, who was shot and killed March 24, 1980, as he celebrated Mass in a San Salvador hospital chapel, received a major boost Feb. 3 when Pope Francis declared him a martyr.

The decision means Romero will likely be beatified this year in San Salvador.

Romero had "small conversions that led up to and prepared him for this experience when Rutilio Grande was assassinated," Zynda said.

Zynda was among several scholars Catholic News Service interviewed during the annual International Conference on Archbishop Oscar Romero at the University of Notre Dame in September.

"There is no doubt that the Grande event was profound," said Michael E. Lee, associate professor of theology at Jesuit-run Fordham University.

"But I think we've come to understand more and more how that was . . . a tipping point, a capstone, a completion of a long process that in many ways we can say was lifelong."


"Conversions happen in moments of being aware of grace and responding to grace in our humanity," Zynda said. "Romero, when he was 13, heard the call to grace to go to the seminary, (then) to the priesthood. He was very faithful."

Following his 1942 ordination, Romero began doctoral studies in Rome, but was called back to El Salvador by his bishop before he could finish his degree.

In El Salvador, he became a devoted priest who plunged himself into his mission and ministry, Zynda said.

"He is an academic at heart with a very sharp mind, someone who is very generous to God within the context of his culture and his own psychological makeup, and he becomes an isolated workaholic."

With no sense of collaboration or delegation, Romero frequently burned himself out and required a series of respites in Mexico. He eventually entered into analysis in the early 1970s with a therapist who told him he had an obsessive-compulsive personality, she said.

"Little by little he begins to understand the ideology of his woundedness," Zynda said. "Instead of him rejecting that, he embraced it. He began to see grace at work in his own woundedness."

In Romero's personal journals, he talks about that moment as one of the most pivotal of his life.

"It helped him to understand where he had come from, what his wound was, which I make the case that he never felt himself (to be) lovable or capable of loving," she said.

Following his appointment as auxiliary bishop of San Salvador, he began to form sincere bonds with friends for the first time in his life and he started to take more personal time away from work, showing a slow evolution, Zynda said.

Though Romero was raised in a poor family, he mainly worked in clerical positions as a priest.

It was not until he was appointed bishop of Santiago de Maria that he truly understood the suffering of the poor working on the coffee plantations in his country, Lee told CNS.

"Here was re-engagement with a pastoral reality of suffering, injustice, malnutrition and just tragic circumstances," Lee said.

"That moment opens him up to think through, 'What does it mean to be a Christian? What does it mean to be a pastor? What does it mean to be Church in the world today in light of suffering like this, in light of injustice like this?'"

While Romero was undergoing a steady conversion, his reputation remained as someone who would not challenge the government in El Salvador or the wealthy power structure, said Julian Filochowski, chairman of the Archbishop Romero Trust in London.

The Salvadoran government welcomed his February 1977 appointment as archbishop, but Romero's conservative reputation concerned many progressive priests. They feared he would suppress their commitment to the poor.

A few weeks later, Father Grande was gunned down on his way to Mass. Romero went to the church where his friend's body had been laid out and prayed with impoverished local farmers who told him about their suffering.


He emerged as the fiery champion of the poor and oppressed, who used the pulpit to denounce actions of the government, death squads in his country, violence from the outbreak of civil war and military occupation of churches, Filochowski told CNS.

"So, the three years of his tenure as archbishop were three years of intensifying conflict in his preaching," he said.

"He spoke the truth, he took the word of God and he unpacked it and he made it real for his people and his poor, and he would make it relevant to their lives and their suffering."