Women should have a larger role in Church, says Durocher

Archbishop Paul-André Durocher

Archbishop Paul-André Durocher

March 7, 2016
MICHAEL SWAN
THE CATHOLIC REGISTER

Archbishop Paul-André Durocher wants to hear the voices of women, take their advice and see them active in the Church.

"Let us accept Pope Francis' invitation to elaborate in our churches a true synodality in which all voices are heard, those of women too," the archbishop of Gatineau wrote in the Feb. 1 issue of the Vatican's semi-official newspaper L'Osservatore Romano.

Durocher was invited to contribute to one of the Church's most influential publications by Lucetta Scaraffia, editor of the paper's monthly supplement called Women Church World. Scaraffia is the Christian feminist who has almost single-handedly redeemed the term feminism inside the Vatican.

For the archbishop of Gatineau, Que., the invitation was a chance to push his arguments for women in the Church deeper than his headline-grabbing proposal to ordain women deacons at last year's Synod on the Family.

Durocher's proposal at that time went beyond just the idea of women deacons and was concerned mainly with violence against women in the family.

When the media reached for a headline in his three-minute speech, Durocher was left frustrated by the shallowness of the resulting debate.

This time he wrote his own headline, "Speaking, advising and deciding: The future of women in the Church."

Durocher's proposals this time include:

"I saw this as an occasion to look at other aspects than simply the question of ordination of women to the diaconate," he told The Catholic Register.

Whether women might be ordained as deacons is an open question debated by canon lawyers, theologians and historians. Durocher recognizes it "would be a huge step within the Church."

But in his essay, Durocher wanted to look at "smaller steps that we could take without changing any structures, any discipline within the Church."

So far, Durocher is only talking about possibilities. If you want to hear a woman or a married couple preach next Sunday, don't rush off to Gatineau's St. Joseph Cathedral.

"I also very much believe in Church unity," the archbishop said. "I don't think it's proper for people to be setting out in directions of their own choosing. . . . We need to debate these ideas and work together."

PLENTY OF ROOM

There's plenty of room within Church practice, liturgical and canon law for experimentation, said Durocher.

In fact, when it comes to women attending plenary meetings and advising bishops' conferences, that's already a reality in Canada.

The Canadian prelate isn't trying to win over women who have dismissed the Church as hopelessly patriarchal - a boys' club bonded by fear and suspicion of women.

IMPOVERISHING OURSELVES

But he does want to talk with women who are frustrated with the pace of change.

"I don't think the purpose of this is to somehow kind of bring back to the fold people who have left," he said.

"For me the question is, we as a Church are impoverishing ourselves by not giving greater space to the voices of women within the decision-making processes of the Church."

Durocher's essay is at osservatoreromano.va/en/news/speaking-advising-and-deciding.