WCR logo
 

Sunday - 05/19/2013

Click for Edmonton City Centre, Alberta Forecast

St. Paul - Mundare St. Paul
Jubilee
2008-2009
Catechism Logo Exploring the
Catholic Catechism
Compendium-Cover
Compendium
of the
Social Doctrine
of the Church

Last Updated: Friday - 09/24/2010


Week of June 16, 2003


Why was the Last Post not played at a funeral?


By SR. LOUISE ZDUNICH, NDC
Edmonton


Some time ago, there was reference in the papers to a priest not allowing the Last Post to be played at the funeral of a priest military chaplain. He did not give a reason. I would like to know why he would not allow it, as I have heard it played at other churches. Has there been a new policy?




I do not know why he took this particular stand. He probably considered it inappropriate, maybe because it is a secular song or it may seem to glorify war. A song's suitability for a church setting is the guiding principle when hymns are chosen, especially for occasions such as funeral and wedding Masses when people like to pick favourites.

Sometimes, people select love songs glorifying infidelity for a wedding. These are totally unacceptable for a Catholic wedding which celebrates a life-long commitment.

For funerals, people may want to choose songs which the deceased loved but which may have nothing to do with God or faith.

Although I hear the bugle sound the Last Post every Nov. 11, I knew very little about it. Therefore, to try to evaluate it, I did some research to find out its history and words. Most of us probably don't think much about its purpose or meaning when we hear it, but it may be helpful to know something about it.

This song originated in 1928 to honour the memory of the soldiers of the British Empire who died at Ypres, Belgium during the First World War. The Belgian people thought they should develop a way to show their gratitude to those who had died for Belgium's freedom.

So a year after the inauguration of the Menin Gate Memorial for the war dead in Ieper, they chose this location as a suitable place for a ceremony honouring the dead because it was through this old city gate that many soldiers passed on their way to battle.

The Last Post, an ode to the fallen, was first played there on July 1, 1928 and has continued every night and in all weathers since Nov. 11, 1929, except during the Nazi occupation in the Second World War.

Those who died remain as the stars in the sky and always will be remembered by those left behind.

Then, the ceremony was moved to Brockwood Military Cemetery in Surrey, England. It resumed at the Menin Gate on the evening of the liberation of Ypres, even though there was still fighting all around. It has also continued to sound at Brockwood Cemetery every first Sunday of the month.

Originally, the Last Post was sounded at sunset but more recently, it has taken place at 8 p.m.

It appears that there is another song called Reveille or Rouse often played with the Last Post. Sometimes, the Last Post begins the silence and Reveille ends it.

In Australia, the Last Post is sounded at 10 p.m. to inform soldiers they should be in their quarters for the night. But it is also sounded at military funerals and memorial services.

In the U.S., Taps is played rather than the Last Post. Although there are no official words to Taps, a popular version bids farewell to the departed soldier along with a prayer for safekeeping and rest in God.

Although usually we hear only the music for the Last Post, I thought it would be interesting to check out the words to see if these may render it improper at the Eucharistic Liturgy in Church.

The words speak of England as a mother mourning her children who have died in the cause of freedom and who are buried far from England's shores. They praise the young who went to war joyfully but who no longer grace us with their presence.

However, those who died remain as the stars in the sky and always will be remembered by those left behind. It is a tribute to those who have died in the service of country and its theme is basically "we will remember them."

Quite touching words, I'd say. However, no prayer is uttered to God for those who have died and actually no mention is made of God at all. In a general sense, it is really something like a eulogy which testifies to the life of the individual who has died, only it does this in a more general sense.

Although we have seen Catholic funerals for prominent people on TV where eulogies are given during the Mass, the Church prefers that the eulogy be given at the Vigil or before or after the Mass rather than during the Mass.

This is because the funeral Mass is not meant to praise the dead, except inasmuch as they lived the Gospel but as a communal celebration of the Eucharist and the homily generally reflects on the Scripture readings.

The Last Post having no mention of God could be considered like the eulogy. This may be one of the reasons the Last Post was not allowed at this particular funeral.


Copyright © 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003, 2004, 2005, 2006, 2007, 2008, 2009 -- Western Catholic Reporter


Our mission: To serve our readers by bringing the Gospel to bear on current issues in the Church and in secular culture through accurate news coverage and reflective commentary.